Containing immigration numbers and fraud

Issue 350 July 15, 2016

Immigration has all the makings of Election 2017 issue.

The change in governments in Australia, United Kingdom, United States of America and possibly other major players in the UN Security Council could have an impact on migration in their respective countries.

There is an outcry in all of them to check migrant inflow.

Immigration is an emotional issue which most ethnic communities would defend as ‘essential.’ Their reasoning is obvious and understandable.

The Ruling National Party and immigration advisors and immigration lawyers are defending a liberal immigration policy. Their reasoning is also obvious, although may not be understandable or even less, acceptable.

A majority of us, including those involved with this newspaper are migrants. The difference is only in the year when migration took place. But all of us went through a robust immigration process- there were no short cuts.

And most of us would prefer a more selective immigration regime.

Auckland breaking

Times have changed and New Zealand, more importantly, Auckland stands at the precipice of breaking down- in terms of infrastructure, housing and other essential supplies. The government’s policy of directing migrants to other smaller cities does not seem to work. Auckland is indubitably the commercial and industrial hub. Migrants know that most employment and business opportunities exist here.

Is Auckland liveable City? Is it a loveable City? Should we not set aside our emotions and approach migration with a sense of purpose and reality?

These questions were posed at a Panel Session organised by Multicultural New Zealand at its Annual General Meeting held in Auckland last month. The Panel comprised five candidates contesting the Auckland Mayoralty.

The opinions were varied.

Winston Peters warning

The views of New Zealand First Leader and senior parliamentarian always provoke public debate. While his comments would anger Asian communities including Indian, mainstream media would support him.

But not this time since most newspapers, radio and television stations are National supporters.

Mr Peters has called for a review of our immigration policy and slow down the process. He has said that too many people are coming into our country and that a majority of them have questionable educational certificates and job experiences.

“The biggest driver of record immigration has been a mass influx of people coming in, many on work visas, and many low skilled, as Treasury points out. (Prime Minister John) Key refuses to recognise that his open door immigration has put enormous pressure on New Zealand – emergency departments are overloaded, schools are struggling to cope, housing is in crisis, wages are depressed, and migrants are being used as cheap labour,” he said.

Mass Rejections

But a recent TVNZ Report should make us think and appreciate Mr Peters’ concern.

The Report said that in the last year, almost 10,000 applications filed by Indians in India were rejected by Immigration New Zealand (INZ).

“A majority of these applications were from unlicensed agents and advisers, who use false educational qualifications and financial statements to apply for student visas and there are warnings the problem could be more widespread,” TVNZ said.

Massey University Pro-Vice-Chancellor (College of Humanities & Social Sciences) Distinguished Professor Paul Spoonley warned that would be an ‘ongoing issue.’

“It is a big industry in India, so I am not surprised at the number that Immigration New Zealand have found. They have a major reputational risk for us as a destination for Indian students; we have to get on top of it because otherwise an important industry in this country is at risk,” he said.

Immigration Minister Michael Woodhouse said that the matter is being investigated.

“INZ and Education NZ have gone into that market to make sure that people are very, very clear about the expectations for being a student in New Zealand,” he said.

Inexcusable methods

The number of cases involving rogue employers, immigration and education advisors and employers who defraud gullible public appears to be on the increase but the trend can be reversed with greater vigilance and discretion.

People should come forward without fear and lodge their complaints with the authorities so that appropriate action can be initiated against the offenders.

Indian Newslink is published by Indian Newslink Limited from its offices located at Level 1, Number 166, Harris Road, East Tamaki, Auckland 2013 and printed at Horton Media Limited, Auckland. All material appearing here and on our web editions are the copyright of Indian Newslink and reproduction in full or part in any medium is prohibited. Indian Newslink and its management and staff do not accept any responsibility for the claims made in advertisements.

Managing Director & Publisher: Jacob Mannothra; Editor & General Manager: Venkat Raman; Production Manager: Mahes Perera; Graphic Designer: Shine Kumar

Phone: (09) 5336377 Email:


Related posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: