I am aware of the view that multiple celebrations of major Indian events like Republic Day, Independence Day and Diwali reflect divisions amongst the groups that host them.
Some therefore say that these occasions should be celebrated as a single event, to which everyone is invited.
I have had some time to reflect on this proposal because it is not new.
This idea received impetus recently because of the low attendance at the 60th Anniversary of India’s Republic Day held at the ASB Theatre on January 24, despite the presence of the Prime Minister, two Mayors and many Ministers and MPs. Another event held at the same time at Telstra Clear Pacific Events Centre attracted about 3000 people.
I attended both events.
Ram Rai wrote in this newspaper (July 15) saying that it was a disappointing experience.
I am not clear what he found most objectionable. Is it the fact that the event attended by the Prime Minister attracted fewer numbers than the Telstra event, or that Indians had chosen to hold two celebrations of India’s Republic Day?
It is not unreasonable to compare such celebrations by people from other countries and cultures. I know that the American Independence Day (July 4) is celebrated in many different places and Americans do not see this as a sign of division. On the contrary, people often go to several July 4 events and enjoy them all. The same can be said about Fiji Day, Canada Day and many others. There are many Diwali, Eid and Chinese New Year celebrations held concurrently in different parts of Auckland and others do not see this as a sign of division.
Why should Indians feel they are somehow being divisive when they choose to do the same? Auckland is a big city and many find it difficult to travel across to various venues.
Having local celebrations provides greater access and enables more people to participate.
It is important not to politicise these celebrations. I mean organisers should give equal focus on all those who come to celebrate with us whether they are politicians, businesses or from other communities. It is very satisfying to see our events attended by other cultures, especially Maori and European. They find our events fascinating, our cultural items enriching and our cuisine enjoyable.
It has taken just over 20 years for the new wave of Indian migrants to be well settled and play an increasingly significant role in their adopted country.
The growing number of overseas and New Zealand-born Indians have made us more visible and as an integral part of this country’s national life. We must celebrate our key events often and with as wide a range of New Zealanders as possible.
This will make New Zealand proud of us and make us proud New Zealanders.
As a member of a political party and as one who has attended many festivals over the last 20 years, I welcome the celebration of our key dates.
All politicians support this and do not see multiple celebrations as somehow disrespectful.
The above Guest Editorial, written by Labour MP Dr Rajen Prasad, does not reflect the views of Indian Newslink. Readers are welcome to respond to editor@indiannewslink.co.nz
