The Treasury leak and smear campaign stink

The Treasury leak and smear campaign stink

Jo Moir

Wellington, June 8, 2019

Finance Minister Grant Robertson (RNZ Photo by Dom Thomas)

Finance Minister Grant Robertson remains under pressure over whether he acted quickly enough to correct allegations of hacking against the opposition.

A furious National Party has called for the resignation of both the minister, Grant Robertson, and Treasury secretary Gabriel Makhlouf for smearing it with claims of hacking.

National Party’s claim

National still claims it did nothing illegal to obtain secret Budget information, as it was done by a search of the Treasury website.

Treasury initially cried foul, saying there had been a “deliberate and systematic hack” and called in the Police. That was last Tuesday (May 28, 2019) night.

Shortly thereafter, Mr Robertson released his own statement linking the National Party to the alleged hack.

It was 2 pm the next day (18 hours later) before he started to refer to it as “unauthorised access’’ and denying any accusations against National.

No hacking

RNZ understands he was told on Tuesday night that the Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) did not agree with the language Treasury was using, and did not believe a “hack” had occurred.

But Mr Robertson told media today he received no advice from the spy agency, or anyone else, before he released his statement.

“I am sure that timeline will come out as we go but I certainly did not know about it before I put my statement out.’’

National’s Paula Bennett said she still believed Mr Robertson had been “out to smear the National Party.”

Police involvement

And she said if he was told afterwards, he should have corrected his statement immediately.

Mr Robertson maintained he was only acting on Treasury advice and did not correct his statements about the hacking because by then Police were involved.

“Clearly it evolved over that period of time and statements were then made by the secretary of Treasury as it should be.”

How it unfolded

It began when a National Party staffer discovered parts of the government’s Budget had been uploaded to the Treasury website.

According to National, that discovery was made at 5 pm on Monday, May 27, 2019.

By 10 am the next morning, they had started drip-feeding details of the Wellbeing Budget – due to be released by Mr Robertson on Thursday (May 30, 2019) to the media.

That evening, Treasury released its statement about the hack.

Mr Robertson put his own statement out shortly after saying: “we have contacted the National Party tonight to request that they do not release any further material, given that the Treasury said they have sufficient evidence that indicates the material is a result of a systematic hack.”

The next morning, Mr Makhlouf went on RNZ Morning Report and described the activity as akin to attempts to prise open the bolt of a door 2000 times until it weakened and the unknown actors got access to the documents.

By Budget Day, the Police had found nothing and decided not to investigate further.

Who else knew?

Mr Robertson said that he spoke with Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters and Green Party Co-Leader James Shaw on Tuesday (May 28, 2019) night to inform them of the advice he had received from Mr Makhlouf.

Other ministers were also informed.

One colleague has described Mr Robertson as “incandescent” over the way the whole situation had been handled by Treasury, saying “you could have plugged him into the grid.”

The State Services Commission is now investigating what Mr Makhlouf said publicly and to the Minister about the unauthorised access, and his decision to refer the matter to the Police.

Speaking yesterday (June 7, 2019), Ms Ardern would not say when she was told about the GCSB advice but insisted Mr Robertson’s job was safe.

Jo Moir is a Political Reporter at Radio New Zealand based in Wellington. The above Report and Picture have been published under a Special Arrangement with

Related posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: