California Court fines New Zealanders for pornography

California Court fines New Zealanders for pornography

Susan Strongman
Wellington, January 7, 2020

Photo: Unsplash/Ross Sneddon

At least 100 women have come forward with new claims that they were coerced to appear in sex videos as part of a multi-million dollar online porn operation, after its New Zealand masterminds were ordered to pay damages by a California court.

Last week, 36-year-old Michael James Pratt and 37-year-old Matthew Isaac Wolfe were ordered to pay $19 million to 22 women, mostly students, aged between 18 and 23.

Pratt is believed to have fled the United States after being indicted for separate criminal charges of sex trafficking by force, fraud and coercion. Wolfe is in federal custody awaiting trial.

Through a series of companies, including several registered to Vanuatu, Pratt owned and received 100 percent of the profits from porn websites, which generated millions annually.

California attorney Ed Chapin, who headed a team representing 22 plaintiffs, says many more women had come forward.

Devastating experience

“It’s been devastating to the 22 and several hundred others. We are getting emails and text messages from other women who have been victimised by this operation as well and they all tell a similar story as to the promises made to them and how they were short changed on the money and how they were promised anonymity and it didn’t come to pass,” Chapin said.

“They were all devastated by it. They have had serious emotional distress, they’re embarrassed, they’re humiliated, they’ve been harassed, intimidated. Their lives have been altered and in many cases they describe it as their lives having been ruined. Some have been suicidal.”

The Judgement

In a judgement released Thursday, January 2, 2020, the two San Diego-based New Zealanders and US citizen Rueben Andre Garcia, a porn actor, were found liable for fraud and breach of contract for lying to women about where the videos would be disseminated, and how much they would be paid for the work. The judge has also ordered that videos and photographs of the women be removed from the website.

According to the judgement, the defendants advertised clothed modelling work on Craiglist in the US and Canada, then convinced young respondents to fly to San Diego to shoot pornographic videos and photographs, promising anonymity and fees of up to $10,500.

“Defendants assure the women that the video will never be seen by anyone they know because it will only be distributed on DVD in a foreign country; it thus will never be available in the United States, and it will never be published online,” the judgement reads.

But videos were distributed online, as well as being sent directly to members of the women’s communities, in some cases including parents, siblings, sports coaches, employers, and university professors.

“Outrageous and despicable”

Approximately 60 emails were sent to one plaintiff’s law school. The women’s names and other personal information was also deliberately disseminated.

Judge Kevin Enright wrote that defendants “immediately benefited” from releasing information into the women’s communities as it increased views and traffic to their websites, increased “name ID” for their brand, and boosted subscription sales.

Lawyer Ed Chapin described Pratt, Wolfe and Garcia’s behaviour as “outrageous, despicable, [and] reprehensible” and said the women were vindicated by the outcome of the 99-day trial.

“Their stories were believed in the face of tremendous opposition efforts to try to discredit them.”

Susan Strongman is a Reporter (In Depth) at Radio New Zealand. The above story and picture have been published under a special agreement with

Photo: Unsplash/Ross Sneddon

Related posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: