Collins dismisses $4 billion error as inconsequential

Jo Moir

Jo Moir

Auckland, September 20, 2020


National Leader Judith Collins at the Party’s virtual campaign launch today (Pool Photo by Hagen Hopkins for Getty Images)

The National Party officially launched its election campaign today, but it was hindered by a $4 billion hole in its flagship economic policy.

The Party’s Finance Spokesperson Paul Goldsmith was forced to concede that his numbers did not add up after Labour revealed the significant gap in its costings.

“This is an irritating mistake. We missed it, and our external checker missed it as well, and that is a mistake that we made,” he said.

The party will now borrow the missing billions, which Mr Goldsmith argued is still far less than what Labour is borrowing.

Error inconsequential: Collins

National Party leader Judith Collins told media after the launch that it was inconsequential in the scheme of things.

“It is actually entirely inconsequential, when we talk about this, I think it is always best to remember 100,000 houses for Kiwibuild. Child Poverty: Children being told that material hardship for children would go down significantly; it has gone up by 4000 children in three years. I think that people understand that an error was made; and it was owned up to and actually I have got no problem with that,” she said.

The error means that National’s intention to bring debt down to 35% of GDP by 2034 will now be revised to 36%.

Ms Collins said that was nothing compared to the 48% Labour had committed.

Mr Goldsmith has apologised to Ms Collins, but she said that she did not need to have words with him because he was a “perfectionist” and felt terrible about the error.

“Goldie is feeling very bad on it and he no doubt told you so,” she said.


National Party Finance Spokesperson Paul Goldsmith at the virtual campaign launch (Pool Photo by Hagen Hopkins for Getty Images)

Extremely basic error: Robertson

Labour is calling the gaffe an “extremely basic error” that calls into question National’s abilities as potential leaders of the country.

Finance Spokesperson Grant Robertson said that the Pre-election Economic and Fiscal Update – the government’s accounting of its books before New Zealanders go to the polls – showed just under $15 billion would become available by cancelling Super Fund contributions for the next decade, not $19 billion that National has claimed.

That leaves National with $4 billion less to draw from to balance planned spending with their promised $4.7 billion worth of tax cuts.

Mr Robertson said that the mistake was easy to find and threw doubt on the Opposition Party’s competency.

“It cuts to whether or not National are able to put forward an economic plan that New Zealanders can believe. I believe this plan is irresponsible and unaffordable, we have now seen a specific example of that. This does go to credibility. It is a mistake clearly that has been made here. And quite clearly, there are not people now involved in putting together this material for National who have been involved in budgets before,” he said.

Labour Finance Spokesperson Grant Robertson (RNZ Picture by Jane Patterson)

Mr Robertson questioned whether there are other mistakes in National’s Policy and said that it is not the time for policy made up on the fly that does not add up.

He suggested National to show the spreadsheets behind its workings and issue a new plan.

Campaign goes virtual

It was a virtual launch at Avalon Studios in Lower Hutt today because of Covid-19 restrictions, with only 100 people socially distanced allowed to attend.

MPs and supporters watched and contributed to the livestream. Some had prepared their audiences well for the lines they wanted delivered – others not so much.

In New Plymouth, it was clear that MPs Jonathan Young, Barbara Kuriger and Harete Hipango had written their scripts on the back of their hand-held placards to which they regularly referred during their brief televised slot.

Ms Collins was the Keynote Speaker at the event hosted by outgoing North Shore MP Maggie Barry.

She used her speech to talk what her Party was promising and what Labour had failed to deliver.

“You will not find a National government wasting taxpayers’ money on expensive failures like KiwiBuild, light rail and a pet Green School. Our policies will grow the economy, not the bureaucracy. National’s policies will grow jobs, smart jobs, high-paying jobs. And there is more to come,” she said.

She is rolling out a new policy announcement tomorrow and said that there will be more throughout the week.

“Everyone knows that it is going to be tough, I just love coming from behind and getting through there.

“I just think that people need to be really positive about the fact we have a plan for New Zealand and for the economy and the current people seem to have no plan except sitting around saying they want to take more money off people,” she told media.

‘Enormous Policy announcement’

While new policy is on the way there was none in sight at the launch.

Ms Collins told media there was never any intention to have any.

“When you have got such an enormous policy announcement like we had on Friday, why would not we want to talk about that, and just talk again about some of the big infrastructure projects because we announced those quite some weeks ago now,’’ she said.

That announcement on Friday was short-term tax cuts, worth $4.7 billion, along with changes to tax thresholds and tax incentives for investments over $150,000.

It is the same announcement that resulted in the $4 billion hole that Labour will no doubt use extensively against National as an example showing why it cannot be trusted with the books.

Jo Moir is a Political Reporter at Radio New Zealand. The above Report and Pictures have been published under a Special Agreement with

Related posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: