Ministry apologies over Car Tax submissions

Jo Moir

The Transport Ministry says that legitimate submissions opposing the Car Tax-Rebate Scheme were wrongly disregarded as spam.

National Party Leader Simon Bridges has accused Associate Transport Minister Julie-Anne Genter of gagging people opposed to the Scheme.

The Ministry is assuring those who have made submissions through the National Party that their views will inform its advice to Associate Transport Minister Julie-Anne Genter.

In July, Ms Genter sought feedback on subsidising lower-emitting cars by levying higher-emitting ones.

On Sunday (September 29, 2019), Mr Bridges accused her of gagging people opposed to the Scheme, because only 500 of the more than 1500 submissions sent through his Party’s website had been accepted.

Assessment promised

Yesterday (September 30, 2019), Ministry Chief Executive Peter Mersi promised a thorough assessment of how the submissions came to be flagged as spam.

“The whole purpose of the public consultation process is for individuals and organisations to voice their views on a Policy proposal. It was wrong for legitimate submissions to be flagged as spam,” Mr Mersi said.

“I want to assure all those who made submissions through the ‘Campaign Now website that their views will be considered as part of the analysis process. Information from the submissions we received will serve to inform the advice given to Ministers on the Policy proposal later this year,” he added.

Apology tendered

Mr Mersi said that he is writing to Mr Bridges to personally apologise for the mistake.

“One thousand, six hundred and forty-four submissions were received from the same email address, and a majority were sent over a short period of time. This, and the fact that the emails themselves were largely identical in content-led Ministry staff to conclude that they were being sent as part of an automated process.

“The Ministry only became aware that the submissions came from a legitimate source following media statements yesterday from the National Party,’’ Mr Mersi said.

In a statement, Mr Bridges said that he was pleased to see the hundreds of New Zealanders who were blocked from having their say on Labour’s Car Tax will now have their submissions counted.

A bad idea

“It is disappointing that we ended up in this situation, to begin with, but credit to the Ministry of Transport for acknowledging its error and taking steps to correct it,” he said.

“The government cannot ignore the fact that its proposed Car Tax is a bad idea. It will increase the price of some of New Zealand’s most popular vehicles by up to $3000, Mr Bridges said.

“This Policy will hurt farmers, tradespeople and low-income earners for whom low-emission vehicles will still be too expensive, and it will only reduce emissions by 0.09% over 20 years, according to Treasury,’’ Mr Bridges said.

Published under a Special Agreement with

Photo Caption:

Julie-Anne Genter (RNZ Picture by Dorn Thomas)

Related posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: