Social media giant faces wide criticism over news ban

Maryke Steffens

Maryke Steffens

Sydney, February 19, 2021

                               Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison slams Facebook in the Federal Parliament                                      on February 18, 2021 (Getty Images)

 Facebook’s decision to ban media organisations from posting links to news articles on the social media giant’s platform comes less than a week before Australia’s Covid-19 Vaccine rollout begins.

The ban also prevented many health organisations, government health departments and other organisations from posting links (some, but not all, have now been restored).

The combined effect of this could be incredibly damaging.

My research is on how poor-quality information and misinformation in online environments, including social media, is presenting serious challenges for public health.

When I saw the news about Facebook’s ban, I was struck by the terrible timing.

Now, more than ever we need credible, evidence-based information about Covid-19 vaccines circulating on social media.

Balance to less credible information

Of course, not all media reporting is perfect. But research by me and others has shown that the media in general plays an important role as gatekeepers and disseminators of high-quality public health information to the public.

You can be critical of individual news organisations or reports while also recognising that much of the media has provided a crucial counterbalance to less credible information and misinformation on social media about vaccines.

We are now at risk of an imbalance in the types of Covid-19 Vaccine information available on social media, just when the public needs reassurance and evidence-based answers to their often quite reasonable questions.

Move catches government sites

The fact that public health organisations and health departments were or are caught up in this — and are or were also reportedly unable to post links to their Facebook pages — is particularly worrying.

Facebook has said that government pages should not be affected, but some have been.

Some have now been restored and Facebook said that it will reverse the ban on any pages accidentally affected. Public health organisations, including government departments, research institutes, charities and not-for-profits do so much in the Vaccine information and hesitancy space.

Genuine concerns

Many people understandably have genuine questions and concerns about Covid-19 Vaccines.

People are really hungry for information right now. One of the main ways people get it is through social media.

Public health organisations support people with concerns on social media by digesting complex information, translating it for non-scientists, and answering questions.

And that’s why this timing is incredibly poor.

Facebook has traditionally been the place where a lot of Vaccine misinformation has been spread. The social media giant does appear to be making an effort to fight misinformation.

It recently did a purge and made it harder for posts by groups spreading Vaccine misinformation to appear in people’s newsfeeds.

Facebook has also pledged to fight misinformation about Covid-19 Vaccines.

But banning links from media and public health organisations, just as we prepare to begin a national vaccine rollout, certainly will not help that effort.

Vaccination message suffers

Many media organisations are possibly planning a lot of coverage to go with the Covid-19 Vaccine rollout.

In general, I have been impressed with the efforts of many media organisations to inform people about the science that underpins the new Covid-19 Vaccines and debunk Vaccine myths and misinformation.

They have been doing a lot of the heavy lifting and complementing the work of public health organisations, many of which lack the budget to do that kind of health messaging on their own. By minimising the media’s role at this moment, Facebook will make it harder for people to access good information, at a time when they need it most.

We are living through a significant public health event.

Facebook has a moral responsibility to support public health messages being put out by experts and the decision does not help achieve that.

Maryke Steffens is Research Affiliate at the University of Sydney, a  Research Fellow at the National Centre for Immunisation Research and Surveillance and a PhD Candidate at Macquarie University,  University of Sydney. The above story and pictures have been published under Creative Commons Licence.

Related posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: